Should This 48-Year-Old Sell Their $450k Rental to Fund a $250k/Year Chubby FIRE Lifestyle?
- Age
- 48
- Net Worth
- $10,280,000
- Expenses
- $250,000/yr
- Location
- HCL
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
With a $10.2M net worth at 48, this investor is evaluating if selling a low-yield, reliable rental property is the best move to optimize their tax strategy for a 2027 retirement.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You have a massive safety margin with over $10M in assets and only $250k in planned annual spending, giving you a very safe withdrawal rate well below 3%.
Areas to Focus
- • Run a sensitivity analysis on the tax impact of selling the property vs. the lost potential rental income and asset appreciation over the next 10 years.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Capital gains tax planning during your Roth conversion window could significantly impact your liquidity if not managed alongside your planned portfolio liquidation.
The Original Post
Militantly single and childless, 48, HCL Plan to retire March 2027 Networth: 5.5m in non-retirement account, mostly in S&P 500 and Total Maket Indices. 3.3 m in IRA and 401 K, same as above with some bonds. 80k cash in SPAXX Primary residence: 950k fully paid. Investment Property: 450k fully paid (rents out at $2300 a month for below market because the long term tenant is absolutely perfect. Pays $600 in condo fees, so net about $1700 a month). Goal: Try my best to spend a minimum of $250k a year in chubby fire which is what my financial planner tell me that I can safely spend since I don't have heirs. Now I am close to retirement, I am forming my withdrawal strategy. I plan to spend the next 20 years doing Roth Conversion and need to keep my AGI low which can be problematic with dividend income and rental income. I also need to pay the capital gain tax on the Roth Conversion with cash. Plan: sell the investment property in 2028 (my 2027 year will include a somewhat large bonus that give me little wiggle room on tax bracket). Use the cash to fund the tax payments and a nice lifestyle while I gradually and methodically do my Roth Conversion and sell my non-retirement portfolio and still stay out of the highest tax bracket for a while. Does this make sense? Am I overlooking anything? My investment property is not really a huge money maker, but my tenant has given me absolutely zero headache since the day he moved in 4 years ago. I told him I won't raise the rent as long as he pays rent in time, keep the property in good condition and never bother me with stuff; both of us have kept our side of the bargain. As a result, I am a little conflicted about selling the place since I don't have the traditional issues of a landlord. Any advice is appreciated. I have a financial planner, but I like to hear everyone's thoughts.