Why This $3.6M fatFIRE Couple Needs $13M: The Healthcare Inflation Problem
- Age
- 48
- Net Worth
- $3,600,000
- Expenses
- $300,000/yr
- Location
- California
- FIRE Status
- Behind
Summary
Mid-40s married couple in CA with $3.6M discovers healthcare inflation requires ultra-conservative withdrawal rates, potentially pushing their FIRE target from $10M to $13M.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Excellent modeling discipline - using detailed FIREcalc scenarios with 8.7% healthcare inflation to stress-test assumptions. Smart recognition that $30k/year healthcare costs require separate treatment from general expenses. Good awareness of ACA subsidy limitations in fatFIRE scenarios and MAGI optimization strategies.
Areas to Focus
- • Consider relocating to a lower healthcare cost state or exploring international healthcare options - California premiums are among the highest nationally, and geographical arbitrage could reduce your required portfolio by $2-3M without compromising care quality.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Overmodeling healthcare inflation creates analysis paralysis - 8.7% perpetual growth assumes worst-case scenarios compound forever. Medicare at 65 dramatically reduces costs, and 20-year bridge planning (45-65) at 2-2.7% SWR for healthcare alone is likely overly conservative when blended with your total expense base.
The Original Post
EDIT: This isn't talking about 1% *overall*, just on the bucket of costs associated with healthcare. However, this has a big impact on your target number. If you expect $300k post-tax expenses including $30k in healthcare, you might expect around $10M to be a reasonable number at 3.5%. But, if your healthcare costs increase by 8% per year, a number with the same failure rate is close to $13M! Your overall starting SWR is around 2.7% instead of 3.5%. I thought I was pretty set on all my modeling, but the recent increase in healthcare costs made me think twice about things. Here in fatFIRE I'm assuming that most of us don't qualify for ACA subsidies, although of course it is possible in certain years with MAGI management tricks. I'm concerned about the impact of health insurance inflation over time. Here in CA, unsubsidized premiums increased by 26% from 2025-2026. I spot-checked a few other states on the ACA marketplace and it's not uncommon to see increases of 10%+. I found a source saying the median increase for the year was 18%. Perhaps 2026 is an anomaly. There is speculation that insurers are raising their rates due to healthy people choosing to go without insurance, which increases the risk pool. However, I'm reading suggestions that premiums typically rise by 6-8% annually, which far exceeds inflation. On top of this, there is the effect of aging. I compared prices in California for a 65-year-old and a 45-year-old to calculate the cost inflation effect of aging. The difference is almost exactly a 2x multiplier, implying an **annual inflation just from aging of 2\^(1/20) = 3.5%**. This doesn't take into account that you get sicker as you get older and your cost increases from that! Let's take an optimistic estimate of: 5% inflation in premiums 3.5% annual increase due to aging This is already an 8.7% annual increase in healthcare costs. The upper end (8% inflation in premiums) gives 11.8%. Now let's imagine our \*only\* costs were healthcare. A typical mid-40s married couple can easily spend $30k annually in 2026 on healthcare. Here's an example run from firecalc with starting portfolio $3.6M, $30k annual expenses, 50-year retirement, 8.675% annual increase in expenses: [https://firecalc.com/index.php?wdamt=30000&PortValue=3600000&term=50&callprocess2=Submit&ss1=0&ssy1=2038&ss2=0&ssy2=2040&signwd1=%2B&chwd1=0&chyr1=2028&wd1infl=adj&signwd2=%2B&chwd2=0&chyr2=2030&wd2infl=adj&signwd3=%2B&chwd3=0&chyr3=2034&wd3infl=adj&holdyears=2025&preadd=0&inflpick=overrideinfl&override\_inflation\_rate=8.675&SpendingModel=constant&age=48&pctlastyear=0&infltype=PPI&fixedinc=Commercial+Paper&user\_bonds=4.0&InvExp=0.18&monte=history&StartYr=1871&fixedchoice=LongInterest&pctEquity=75&mix1=10&mix2=10&mix3=10&mix4=40&mix5=40&mix6=10&mix7=15&mix8=5&user\_inflation=3.0&monte\_growth=10&monte\_sd=10&monte\_inflation=3.00&signlump1=%2B&cashin1=0&cashyr1=2028&signlump2=%2B&cashin2=0&cashyr2=2038&signlump3=%2B&cashin3=0&cashyr3=2043&process=survival&showyear=1960&delay=10&goal=95&portfloor=0&FIRECalcVersion=3.0&](https://firecalc.com/index.php?wdamt=30000&PortValue=3600000&term=50&callprocess2=Submit&ss1=0&ssy1=2038&ss2=0&ssy2=2040&signwd1=%2B&chwd1=0&chyr1=2028&wd1infl=adj&signwd2=%2B&chwd2=0&chyr2=2030&wd2infl=adj&signwd3=%2B&chwd3=0&chyr3=2034&wd3infl=adj&holdyears=2025&preadd=0&inflpick=overrideinfl&override_inflation_rate=8.675&SpendingModel=constant&age=48&pctlastyear=0&infltype=PPI&fixedinc=Commercial+Paper&user_bonds=4.0&InvExp=0.18&monte=history&StartYr=1871&fixedchoice=LongInterest&pctEquity=75&mix1=10&mix2=10&mix3=10&mix4=40&mix5=40&mix6=10&mix7=15&mix8=5&user_inflation=3.0&monte_growth=10&monte_sd=10&monte_inflation=3.00&signlump1=%2B&cashin1=0&cashyr1=2028&signlump2=%2B&cashin2=0&cashyr2=2038&signlump3=%2B&cashin3=0&cashyr3=2043&process=survival&showyear=1960&delay=10&goal=95&portfloor=0&FIRECalcVersion=3.0&) This shows a failure rate of \~4%, from a withdrawal rate of 0.8%! Even if you only consider 20 years to get from 45 to 65 and plan on having much lower costs in medicare, you still have to have 2-2.7% SWR for healthcare expenses. **This seems very over-conservative, so what's the flaw in this analysis?** Given all this, how are you modeling healthcare? Are you lumping it in with all other expenses and assuming typical inflation? Do you apply a higher inflation rate for healthcare?