FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

ChubbyFIRE Check: $4.84M NW (Excl. Home), $144k–168k Spend, 3 Kids — Keep 2.5% Mortgage or Pay It Off?

r/ChubbyFIRE
8/5/2025
Age
48
Net Worth
$4,840,000
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This couple, aged 48 and 46, have an impressive net worth of $4.84 million, excluding their $1.3 million home. With substantial assets in cash, retirement accounts, and a taxable brokerage, they are well-positioned for a comfortable and secure financial future. They are actively planning for their retirement and their children's college expenses, demonstrating a proactive approach to their financial goals.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • The couple has done an excellent job of accumulating substantial wealth, diversifying their assets, and planning for their future expenses. Their focus on fully funding their children's college costs and maintaining a manageable spending plan are positive steps towards achieving financial independence.

Areas to Focus

  • • To further optimize their retirement plan, the couple could consider a tax-efficient drawdown strategy to bridge the gap until age 59.5, as well as explore healthcare options, such as ACA or private plans, for when they both retire. Additionally, they may want to evaluate the pros and cons of paying off their mortgage early versus maintaining the low-interest rate.

The Original Post

TL;DR: We’re 48 and 46 with three kids (college, high school, and middle school) in California, and have a net worth of $4.84M excluding our home. Assets include $2M cash, $2.2M in 401(k)s, and $520k taxable. Our home is worth $1.3M with a $300k mortgage at 2.5%. Current spending is $12k/month (covered under spouse’s employer health insurance). Once both of us retire, spending would increase to $14k/month with ACA coverage, then drop to $11k/month after the mortgage is paid off. Should we retire now (one of us) and keep the mortgage, or pay it off? ⸻ 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Ages & Family     •    Me: 48 (planning to retire now) — current salary ~$200k + ~$140k/year in potential RSUs     •    Spouse: 46 (may work a bit longer) — salary ~$150k/year with employer health insurance for family     •    Kids: 19, 15, 11 — plan to fully fund all college expenses     •    Location: California (high COL) ⸻ 💰 Assets     •    $2.0M cash in HYSAs (recent stock sale — plan to DCA into diversified portfolio over the next 6–12 months; $150k already earmarked for college)     •    $2.2M in 401k (pre-tax)     •    $520k taxable brokerage (stocks/funds)     •    NW excluding home: ~$4.84M     •    Home value: ~$1.3M     •    Mortgage: $300k @ ~2.5% interest ⸻ 📉 Liabilities     •    Mortgage payment: $2,400/mo PITI + $600 extra principal ⸻ 💸 Spending Goals     •    Base target: $12k/mo net (~$144k/year) covering living expenses, travel, hobbies, etc.     •    College for 19, 15, and 11-year-old fully funded via earmarked cash and taxable assets     •    If both retire → add ~$2k/month for ACA/private health insurance (estimate based on current Covered California premiums) = ~$14k/month while mortgage is still in play     •    Once mortgage is gone → ~$11k/month     •    All spending figures are in today’s dollars; assuming ~2–3% long-term inflation and will adjust withdrawals accordingly. ⸻ 🏥 Healthcare     •    Covered under spouse’s employer plan until both retired     •    Will need ACA or private plan for a family of five once both are retired ⸻ ❓ Key Questions     1.    Are we ready for one to retire now, with the other following in 1–3 years?     2.    Best tax-efficient drawdown strategy to bridge to age 59.5?     3.    ACA/private healthcare strategies for a family of five in California once both retired?     4.    Mortgage question: Keep paying down mortgage slowly since the rate is only 2.5%, or pay it off early to reduce monthly expenses? Thank you for the advice in advance.