Torn Between Two Coasts: $5.3M Couple Debates Trading California Sunshine for Manhattan Dreams
- Age
- 48
- Net Worth
- $5,300,000
- Location
- Orange County, California
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
48-year-old couple with $5.3M net worth exploring retirement to Manhattan while weighing California roots and aging parents.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Strong financial position with $4M+ portfolio and paid-off $1.3M house providing flexibility. Smart approach testing NYC with $3k/month vacation budget before committing. Strategically planning around California's Prop 60/90 rules to preserve property tax basis until age 55.
Areas to Focus
- • Define your actual annual expense needs before making the NYC decision - knowing whether you need $150k or $250k annually will determine if selling the house for $6k/month NYC rent truly works with the 4% rule on your portfolio.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Timing risk of becoming renters in an unpredictable NYC market while giving up California property tax protections and home equity appreciation - if NYC real estate significantly outpaces California or rental costs surge, you could lose housing security with aging parents nearby who may need support.
The Original Post
48 year old childless couple from OC in SoCal, privileged to be considering chubby retirement in the next few years with a $1.3m house and $4m+ portfolio. Original plan was to stay in OC until we turn 55, then California law allows us to transfer our property tax basis to another home, maybe downsize to a condo in LA to be near aging parents. While I've enjoyed life in California, I'd always dreamed of living in Manhattan, but my career kept us local. If the point of ChubbyFIRE is having options, I'm thinking about what we can do to explore that dream of NYC life. One option is to keep working, build enough wealth to own property on both coasts, treat one as a vacation home. This option feels the most extravagant and least money/time efficient. Another option is to eventually pull up stakes from California when we don't want to drive anymore. Proceeds from the house and eliminating cars from our budgets could free up $6k+ per month to rent in NYC. I think that's enough for a decent apartment in Midtown? If NYC and California real estate do not outpace each other, this could work, but we would lose the security of being home owners. I have no idea what it would take to own an apartment in Manhattan, or if that's even a good idea. Another option could be to use some of our vacation budget to slow travel there, see if it's something we want to commit to full time. We had been planning for chubby vacation and restaurant budgets, $3k/$2k per month, we could spend half a year's travel budget to live in NYC for a month or whatever. Anyone else thinking about retiring to NYC? What are your projected budgets looking like for housing, etc? Are there other costs or options I should think about?