ChubbyFIRE at 49: Is $3.8M Enough to Support a $250k Annual Lifestyle?
- Age
- 49
- Net Worth
- $3,820,000
- Income
- $397,000/yr
- Expenses
- $250,000/yr
- Profession
- Small business owner
- Location
- SoCal, USA
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 49-year-old business owner and his wife have built an impressive $3.8M portfolio and are planning their transition toward a $250k/year retirement lifestyle.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • With a 99.9% success rate in Monte Carlo modeling if the wife works 3 more years, the plan is robust; keeping the rental property is an excellent hedge against early sequence of returns risk.
Areas to Focus
- • Develop a concrete tax-efficient plan for the bridge years, specifically mapping out the Roth conversion strategy and healthcare coverage costs before the wife's pension kicks in.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Sequence of returns risk during the initial 5-year gap before the pension starts, especially if the rental property is liquidated too early.
The Original Post
Most people here target a portfolio number. My wife’s number was being able to spend **$250k/yr** in retirement. I think we’ve hit it and I’d like a sanity check. **About us** * Me: 49, self-employed. I make $100–150k/yr from a small business with 2 f/t employees. * Wife: 47, public employee earning about $247k/yr. She plans to work about 3 more years, until she turns 50 in Sept 2029. * One kid, 16, starting college in fall 2028. College is covered by a separate \~$146k savings account, which isn’t counted below. * We live in SoCal (HCOL). **My plan** * Starting today, I’d spin the business off to my employees. This would take a couple years (1-2?) and generate some income as it happens. * I’d keep consulting in my industry part-time and maybe pick up a side gig, which would loosely be considered "BaristaFIRE", though I don't want to work much. * Our full retirement would start when my wife retires in 2029. **Invested assets: \~$2.91M** |Account|Amount| |:-|:-| |My taxable brokerage|$1.81M| |My rollover IRA|$364k| |My SEP-IRA|$94k| |Wife’s 457(b)|$264k| |Wife’s rollover IRA|$253k| |Wife’s supplemental city pension (DC)|$122k| That’s roughly $1.8M taxable and $1.1M pre-tax. **Real estate** * Primary home: worth \~$1.71M, $413k mortgage, \~$1.3M equity. Not counted. * Small multi-unit rental: worth \~$1.11M, $197k mortgage, \~$913k equity. It grosses $72.6k/yr in rent. We’ll sell it eventually. **Investable net worth, excluding the home: \~$3.82M** **Guaranteed income later** * Wife’s pension (2% @ 55 formula, \~19.7 years of service by 2029): I modeled it starting at 55, about $99k/yr. * Social Security at 62: me \~$30k/yr, her \~$35k/yr. **Deterministic model** (6% nominal returns, 3% inflation, no withdrawals until 2030, rental sold) |Year|Our ages|Portfolio|Withdrawal|WR| |:-|:-|:-|:-|:-| |2030|53/50|$4.56M|$250k|5.5%| |2035 (pension starts)|58/55|$4.60M|$191k|4.2%| |2039 (my SS)|62/59|$4.94M|$192k|3.9%| |2042 (her SS)|65/62|$5.24M|$179k|3.4%| **Monte Carlo** (10,000 runs, 45 years, 5% real return, 12% standard deviation, $250k real spending) |Scenario|Keep rental|Sell rental| |:-|:-|:-| |We both retire today|97.2%|69.1%| |Wife works 3 more years|99.9%|88.0%| |Wife works 4 more years|100%|92.1%| That model doesn’t count any of my consulting income, so it should be conservative. **My questions** 1. The first 5 years of withdrawals run at \~5.5–6% before her pension starts. Is keeping the rental until 2035 the right sequence-risk buffer, or am I overthinking it? 2. Does it make sense for me to downshift (or... stop) now while she works 3 more years? 3. Anything obvious I’m missing? I’m thinking about Roth conversions in the gap years, health insurance, and how to structure the business spin-off.