FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

How a 50-Year-Old Couple with $4.1M is Rethinking Traditional RMD Withdrawal Strategies

r/financialindependence
7/4/2026
Age
50
Net Worth
$4,100,000
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

This couple is expertly managing a $4.1M portfolio and exploring innovative tax-deferred withdrawal strategies to mitigate future RMD tax impacts.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have done an incredible job accumulating $4.1M through diligent 401k maxing and disciplined brokerage contributions over the last 15+ years.

Areas to Focus

  • • Consult a tax professional or specialized CPA regarding a Roth conversion ladder analysis versus your RMD strategy to ensure tax-efficient withdrawals.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-concentration in tax-deferred accounts may result in significant tax burdens during RMD years if current projections for a $6M+ balance manifest.

The Original Post

Everywhere I have read/heard that one is supposed to use taxable brokerage accounts first and then use tax deferred accounts like 401k next, and Roth last (if you have it). I certainly understand why Roth should be used last, but have a question about the other 2. In our case (early 50s), we have been maxing out our 401ks for past 15+ years, and consequently have $2.8M in tax deferred accounts. About 9 years ago, I decided to systematically start building up a brokerage account and an emergency fund. As of now, we have $1.3M in these - of that $950k is in brokerage and $350k in cash/CD (I know this is a rather large emergency fund, but it gives peace of mind and earns 3.5% interest). The brokerage account is great to use as a bridge if we lose our jobs at any time before getting to age 62 (social security retirement age), but if we can hang on to our jobs till then and keep saving, my estimate is that we will reach about $5-6M in tax deferred and $2-2.5M in brokerage plus cash. Now everyone says having $5-6M in tax deferred around 62 will result in a big RMD problem at 75. Hence, what if we exclusively draw from the tax deferred accounts (like 4-5% per year) in the first decade of retirement and leave the taxable brokerage accounts alone to keep growing and compounding? This is counter to the standard advice, but will solve the RMD issue for us at least without having to implement fancy Roth conversions. What do y’all think??