ChubbyFIRE at 50: Choosing the Best Planning Tool for a $4M Milestone
- Age
- 50
- Net Worth
- $4,000,000
- Location
- Southern California
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This couple is closing in on a $4M net worth and planning for retirement by 2030. They are currently comparing DIY financial planning software to manage their tax and relocation strategies.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Your current strategy of index funds and no mortgage is excellent for maintaining a $4M portfolio.
Areas to Focus
- • Choose a planning tool based on the complexity of your tax planning needs rather than just the visual interface.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Overestimating the impact of state tax relocation while underestimating complex withdrawal tax consequences.
The Original Post
I’m sure this has been asked before, but I’d love input from anyone who has used both Boldin and ProjectionLab, especially those in a similar situation. My wife and I are both 50-ish, no kids, living in Southern California. We own our home outright (no mortgage), both have W-2 income, no side hustles, no rental properties, and our investments are intentionally simple: low-cost index funds across 401(k)/Roth 401(k), Roth IRA, HSA, taxable brokerage, cash, and I Bonds. We’re targeting retirement around January 2030, with a current net worth just under $4M. What we’re looking for is software that helps with decision-making and long-term planning—things like: * relocating out of California * Roth conversion planning * withdrawal/tax strategy * general progress tracking / “are we still on track?” ProjectionLab looks visually great and seems powerful, but I’ll admit I’m not especially tech-savvy, so it feels a little intimidating. Boldin seems more established and perhaps more straightforward, though I’m less drawn to the interface. One other note: we’re not looking for full-service advisory help. We already work with an hourly financial/tax professional and feel good about our overall plan. This is really about choosing the best DIY planning tool. For those who’ve used one or both, what pushed you in one direction or the other? Any regrets?