Should This 50-Year-Old Take a Tax Hit Now to Avoid a $560k RMD Nightmare Later?
- Age
- 50
- Net Worth
- $560,000
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At age 50, this individual is facing a significant required minimum distribution (RMD) of over $560k in the future, which could have major tax implications. They are considering taking a large Roth conversion now to avoid the future tax burden, but the upfront tax hit is a difficult decision. Their detailed analysis of different AGI and Roth conversion scenarios provides helpful context to evaluate the trade-offs.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Doing a great job analyzing the tax implications of Roth conversions vs. future RMDs. The detailed projections and scenarios show a strong understanding of tax planning.
Areas to Focus
- • Consider speaking to a financial advisor to get a professional opinion on the optimal Roth conversion strategy, taking into account your full financial picture and future goals.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ The large future RMD could impact ACA subsidies and lead to a higher overall tax rate. Make sure to model out the full tax implications, including healthcare costs.
The Original Post
I'm facing a conservative projection of 560k+ in RMD's even if I converted 100k per year starting today. However it's a very hard pill to swallow taking a huge tax hit now at age 50. The total tax contains 1 month ACA premium, because I would be jumping off of Medicaid in December. For 2025 I'm curious which AGI scenario would you pick (LTCG is long term capital gain): * AGI 99,900: * LTCG 63900, 31k Roth Conversion. Total Tax 2854.86 Rate 2.86%. * LTCG 35000, 60k Roth Conversion. Total Tax 4875.88 Rate 4.88%. * AGI 128,200: * LTCG 92200, 31k Roth Conversion. Total Tax 5694.46 Rate 4.44% * LTCG 63300, 60k Roth Conversion. Total Tax 8571.65 Rate 6.69%. * AGI 200,000 (larger LTCG provides money to pay for the tax): * LTCG 164k, 31k Roth Conversion. Total tax 21287.86 Rate 10.64%. * LTCG 95k, Roth 100k Conversion. Total Tax 29078.86 Rate 14.54% * AGI 300,000 (larger LTCG provides money to pay for the tax):: * LTCG 167k, Roth 128k Conversion. Total Tax 54117.81 Rate 18.04% * AGI 400,000 (larger LTCG provides money to pay for the tax): * LTCG 167k, Roth 228K Conversion, Total Tax 82820.86 Rate 20.71% For 2026 I was originally aiming for the scenario below because the tax rate was a SWEET 1.5%, but then I dug deeper into my current RMD situation. When taking into consideration the yearly ACA premium for higher income levels I was hitting a total Tax rate of 28%+. That makes the decision much more difficult. * 2026 AGI 73430, 31k Roth Conversion. * LTGC 37430, 31k Roth. Total tax 1104.85 Rate 1.5% Also, what website/software are you using to project the impact of Roth conversions on future RMDs. Right now I'm just using spreadsheet.