FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Should This 50-Year-Old Take a Tax Hit Now to Avoid a $560k RMD Nightmare Later?

r/financialindependence
9/18/2025
Age
50
Net Worth
$560,000
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At age 50, this individual is facing a significant required minimum distribution (RMD) of over $560k in the future, which could have major tax implications. They are considering taking a large Roth conversion now to avoid the future tax burden, but the upfront tax hit is a difficult decision. Their detailed analysis of different AGI and Roth conversion scenarios provides helpful context to evaluate the trade-offs.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Doing a great job analyzing the tax implications of Roth conversions vs. future RMDs. The detailed projections and scenarios show a strong understanding of tax planning.

Areas to Focus

  • • Consider speaking to a financial advisor to get a professional opinion on the optimal Roth conversion strategy, taking into account your full financial picture and future goals.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The large future RMD could impact ACA subsidies and lead to a higher overall tax rate. Make sure to model out the full tax implications, including healthcare costs.

The Original Post

I'm facing a conservative projection of 560k+ in RMD's even if I converted 100k per year starting today. However it's a very hard pill to swallow taking a huge tax hit now at age 50. The total tax contains 1 month ACA premium, because I would be jumping off of Medicaid in December. For 2025 I'm curious which AGI scenario would you pick (LTCG is long term capital gain): * AGI 99,900: * LTCG 63900, 31k Roth Conversion. Total Tax 2854.86 Rate 2.86%. * LTCG 35000, 60k Roth Conversion. Total Tax 4875.88 Rate 4.88%. * AGI 128,200: * LTCG 92200, 31k Roth Conversion. Total Tax 5694.46 Rate 4.44% * LTCG 63300, 60k Roth Conversion. Total Tax 8571.65 Rate 6.69%. * AGI 200,000 (larger LTCG provides money to pay for the tax): * LTCG 164k, 31k Roth Conversion. Total tax 21287.86 Rate 10.64%. * LTCG 95k, Roth 100k Conversion. Total Tax 29078.86 Rate 14.54% * AGI 300,000 (larger LTCG provides money to pay for the tax):: * LTCG 167k, Roth 128k Conversion. Total Tax 54117.81 Rate 18.04% * AGI 400,000 (larger LTCG provides money to pay for the tax): * LTCG 167k, Roth 228K Conversion, Total Tax 82820.86 Rate 20.71% For 2026 I was originally aiming for the scenario below because the tax rate was a SWEET 1.5%, but then I dug deeper into my current RMD situation. When taking into consideration the yearly ACA premium for higher income levels I was hitting a total Tax rate of 28%+. That makes the decision much more difficult. * 2026 AGI 73430, 31k Roth Conversion. * LTGC 37430, 31k Roth. Total tax 1104.85 Rate 1.5% Also, what website/software are you using to project the impact of Roth conversions on future RMDs. Right now I'm just using spreadsheet.