FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

$7.2M at 50: Should This Couple Aggressively Convert at 32% or Play It Safe for Retirement at 52?

r/ChubbyFIRE
3/6/2026
Age
50
Net Worth
$7,200,000
Income
$450,000/yr
Expenses
$200,000/yr
Profession
Independent Contractors
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

50-year-old couple with $7.2M net worth on track to retire at 52 with strategic tax planning. Deciding between aggressive Roth conversions (32% bracket) and conservative brokerage preservation.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Excellent foundation with $7.2M net worth and fully funded 529 plan. Strong income preservation strategy with $3.3M in 401(k), $2.2M deferred comp, and $900k taxable brokerage providing multiple income levers. Pension starting at 65 ($84k/year) and Social Security at 70 (~$100k) creates a solid safety net.

Areas to Focus

  • • Model the deferred comp 5-year rule timing precisely with your CPA before pulling the trigger at 52. This single decision could save $50k-$100k+ in taxes and prevent liquidity surprises between ages 52-62.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ The aggressive 32% conversion strategy exhausts $330k/year from taxable accounts, draining your $900k brokerage within 3 years. If markets decline or expenses exceed projections, you'd be forced to take larger pretax distributions at inopportune times. Your 10-year gap (52-62) before deferred comp and pension income is tight.

The Original Post

Hi everyone, long-time lurker. I hope to pull the trigger at 52 (spouse 51) and wanted to get some feedback on our tax strategy and whether our liquidity bridge is too tight. Background • Age/Family: 50M/ 49F, Two kids (one in college, one in HS). • combined income: 400-500k (50/50 split), both took IC roles and relatively low stress jobs • primary house paid off, no other debt • college fund: 529 fully funded for flagship state school The Numbers: • Net Worth: \~$7.2M • Pre-tax 401(k): $3.3M (The primary "tax bomb" concern) • Deferred Comp: $2.2M • Roth IRA: $600k • Taxable Brokerage/Cash: $900k • HSA: $220k • Current expenses: $100k after tax, excluding tuition • Retirement expenses: $100k + $30k additional travel budget + $30k healthcare; budgeting $200k with tax Income Stream Post-Retirement: • Ages 52-5x: Zero ordinary income. Living off Brokerage/cash. Not quite sure what x is • Ages 5x- 65: Distribution from Deferred Comp. I guess I can use the 5 year rule to postpone/manage the cash flow to hopefully a stable level • Age 65+: $84k combined Pension starts, each about $42k • Age 70+: \~$100k Social Security (couple). The Strategy: I’ve modeled a "controlled burn" of the 401(k). I’m considering slamming the 32% bracket (up to \~$545k gross) for the first few years while I have no other income. This would move \~$515k/year into Roth. From age 5x onwards, I'll drop back to filling the 24% bracket top-off. The whole purpose here is to reduce RMD amount. The Math at Age 75: I can just fill the 24% bracket from the start, but front- load at 32% for a few years seems have better results in terms of overall tax paid. The Dilemma / OMY Question: The 32% strategy is expensive. Between a $200k target spend (lifestyle + all taxes) and the \~$130k federal/state/local tax bill on the conversions, I’m burning \~$330k/year. This effectively exhausts my brokerage and cash account quickly. I have learned a lot from this sub and would love to hear your thoughts. If you were me, what would you do?