Couple Divided: $5.5M at 52 and 57 - Retire Now or Wait 3 More Years?
- Age
- 52
- Net Worth
- $5,500,000
- Expenses
- $160,000/yr
- Location
- MCOL area
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
Married couple with $5.5M net worth and paid-off home ready to retire, but healthcare concerns and differing risk tolerance creating tension.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Outstanding position with $5.5M net worth and zero debt including paid-off $750k home. Your $3.4M in investment accounts can easily support $160k annual spending using a 4% withdrawal rate ($136k). Rule of 55 access to the 57yo's $460k 401k provides immediate liquidity without penalties.
Areas to Focus
- • Bridge the healthcare gap by modeling ACA subsidies with strategic Roth conversions - at $160k spending, you'll likely qualify for significant premium tax credits by keeping taxable income under $70k through 2025 ARPA extensions, potentially reducing that $35k healthcare cost by 50-70%.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Healthcare cost assumption of $35k annually may be overstated without exploring ACA subsidy optimization. Additionally, working 3 more years purely for security means potentially sacrificing $480k in opportunity cost (travel/time) when you're already at 34x your annual spending with diversified accounts and Rule of 55 access.
The Original Post
I wanted to throw the current situation out there just to get folks opinions on what we are considering. Married gay couple, 52 and 57yo, living in a MCOL area and not planning on moving. No debt other than $50K of 0% credit card offers that we will pay off in the next 12 months as the rate nears expiring. No mortgage, no car payments. **Combined investments** (all invested with 80/20 stock/bond split)**:** $1.5M in investments in total **52 yo has** (overall invested with 80/20 stock/bond split)**:** $64K in Roth IRA $1.1M in 401k $550K in Roth 401k **57 yo has** (overall invested in bonds / conservative)**:** $460K in 401k (we have access to it due to Rule of 55) $200K in Roth IRA $640K in IRA Home is worth approximately $750k and has no mortgage. We both will pull around $2400 each at 62 from SS. Total net worth is approximately $5.5M **The targeted annual spend is:** $80K the usual expenses $35K on health insurance / health care from ACA $45K on travel These spend numbers to not include fed/state income taxes as that will vary depending on where the funds are sourced from. I feel like we are well positioned to call it quits, travel, and enjoy life. The other half doesn't agree, with healthcare being the primary concern. He says one of us should work until we are 55 and 60 yo and then take SS at 62 for both of us for the secured income stream. This would give us both access to our 401k accounts at 55 for more flexibility along with the investment accounts. Any thoughts or comments would be appreciated.