FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

52-Year-Old Couple with $6.5M Debates SEPP 72T Strategy for Early Retirement

r/ChubbyFIRE
12/5/2025
Age
52
Net Worth
$6,500,000
Expenses
$300,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Married couple at 52 planning to FIRE in months with $6.5M net worth and $300K annual expenses. Evaluating SEPP 72T vs taxable-first withdrawal strategy.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Excellent asset allocation across taxable ($1.4M), deferred ($3.1M), and exempt ($2M) accounts provides tax flexibility. Your $6.5M portfolio far exceeds the 25x expenses rule ($7.5M needed) at 21.7x current expenses. Smart thinking on SEPP 72T to access deferred funds penalty-free before 59.5, generating $240K annually which covers most of your $300K needs.

Areas to Focus

  • • Run detailed tax projections comparing both strategies over 7.5 years until age 59.5 - SEPP locks you in but may provide better tax efficiency than depleting $1.4M taxable in just 5 years, which could push you into higher brackets later and create a tax bomb when required RMDs hit.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Your $300K annual spending represents a 4.6% withdrawal rate on $6.5M, which is above the safe 4% rule and concerning for a potentially 40+ year retirement starting at 52. After buying the $500K vacation home, you'll have $6M supporting $300K spend (5% rate), plus vacation home maintenance/taxes could push expenses higher.

The Original Post

My wife and I are both 52 and likely FIREing in the next few months. I spoke to my Merrill planner about withdrawal strategy and they are not much help. All they wanted was for me to give them more money (they only have one of my IRAs). Anyway, we have 6.5M, 1.4M taxable, 3.1M deferred, and 2M exempt. My expenses will be about 300k annually, at least for the next 10 years. Was planning on taking 500k of the taxable to buy a vacation home (mortgage costs are included in the 300k) Option 1 would be to use all my taxable accounts first, then the typical withdrawal order, but my plan says I may not make it to 59.5 and don't want to limit myself. Option 2 would be to take SEPP 72T distributions. I calculate it out to about 240k annually, and about 205k after taxes. The remainder I would take out of the taxable account. I would also take out my roth contributions in the first year before starting the SEPP. Was also planning to wheel options to supplement my income, but this will just be an extra kicker. I think option 2 is the better choice, but wondering if I am missing anything? Thanks, everyone!