FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Pre-tax vs. Roth 457(b): A 53-Year-Old's Tax Strategy Dilemma

r/FinancialPlanning
6/11/2026
Age
53
Net Worth
$1,639,000
Income
$150,000/yr
Profession
Government Employee
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

At 53 with $1.6M in assets and a solid pension plan, this couple is optimizing their tax strategy before retirement in 3-5 years.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You have a strong foundation with $1.6M and a future pension; prioritizing pre-tax contributions can significantly lower your current 2025 tax liability.

Areas to Focus

  • • Calculate your projected retirement tax bracket versus your current marginal rate to determine if the tax-free growth of Roth outweighs immediate tax savings.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Over-focusing on Roth at this high-income stage might waste the opportunity to avoid higher current taxes.

The Original Post

My employer (state government) offers a voluntary 457(b) deferred compensation plan in addition to the mandatory pension plan.  The 457(b) has both pre-tax and ROTH options and I’m trying to decide which would be most beneficial for me.  While I would love to reduce my current tax burden, and I’ve always assumed that my tax bracket would be lower in retirement than during my work years, I’m now starting to wonder if I should maximize my tax-free income in retirement by utilizing the Roth option.  I plan to work an additional 3- 5 more years before early retirement.  Some details about my situation:                                                                                                               ​ 53 (me) and 46 (wife) years old.  Dual income, no kids, no debt. ​ Retirement accounts: Roth IRAs: $410K SEP, TSP, Trad IRAs: $192K Pension at 65yo: $30-$40K/year Brokerage: $337K Inherited stock: $700K 2025 AGI of $170K and annual salary of $150K (some dividend and rental income that fluctuates year to year).  I have an HSA which I can max out. What’s my move with the 457(b)?  Roth or pre-tax?  Thanks! Still learning and trying to make good decisions with my money.