FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Did I Accidentally Retire at 54? $1.75M and Doubting My Financial Advisor

r/Fire
11/15/2025
Age
54
Net Worth
$1,750,000
Expenses
$48,000/yr
Profession
Former federal worker
Location
HCOL area, USA
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Single 54F with $1.75M portfolio and zero debt questioning if she can sustain $48K annual spending after leaving work early. Concerned about advisor's optimistic projections.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You're in excellent shape with $1.75M against $48K expenses (36x coverage vs 25x needed), zero debt, and a paid-off $400K home providing housing security. Your conservative 2.7% withdrawal rate leaves significant cushion, plus you have $18K/yr Social Security kicking in at 65 to drop your portfolio draw to just $30K annually.

Areas to Focus

  • • Immediately eliminate the $15K annual advisor fee (0.86% on your portfolio) - this is costing you nearly $400K over 20 years and you're already financially literate enough to manage index funds yourself or use a one-time fee-only planner for $2-3K.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Your advisor may be incentivized to keep you spending aggressively to maintain his 1% fee stream - his $5K/month suggestion ($60K/yr) at a 3.4% withdrawal rate is higher than your conservative targets and his annual fee alone represents 31% of your desired spending, creating a major drag on long-term portfolio sustainability.

The Original Post

It's been a rough year. My plan was always to FIRE, though I intended to work for another 5 yrs. Due to extenuating circumstances, I left my job in Feb with intent to spend a 'gap year' dealing with life, then go back. Meanwhile, the USA has, um, changed significantly and I'm wondering if I really want/need to look for something else? With my new circumstances, I would probably not earn more than 40K. Maybe better to just relax into this with leanFIRE. Would y'all please vet my numbers? \---- I am single 54f, zero debts, grown & independent kids who I doubt will be caring for me in old age. While I've been off work, I've drawn $3500/mo to cover expenses and lived at a comfortable level. Nothing extravagant, not going without. I might need to bump that up to $4K/mo with increased health premiums next year. 520K trad IRA, 135K Roth 210K TSP (mostly pre-tax) from past federal work 875K in a brokerage account 10K lingering in a 529 acct and 15K cash currently Total \~1.75M I own my 400K house in a HCOL, could be downsized in a better market. 18K/yr in SS at 65, if it is still around then. Insubstantial fed pension at 65, maybe 3K/yr, not eligible for the health benefits. From the stuff I've read here, a 3% withdraw rate is sustainable long term. But I'm also aware that markets are at all time highs and everyone is talking about an AI bubble. I'm working on bringing my monthly spending down now that some major stressors are mostly resolved. Thoughts? \*Also, paying a financial advisor 1%, figure $15K annually. He makes everything convenient for me - I'd have no idea how to do most of this on my own. We talked a year ago, and six months ago, and he thought it would be possible for me to not go back to work. In a more recent discussion, he thought I could spend up to 5K/mo, not including taxes, health ins, or his fees. That seems questionable to me! Beginning to wonder if he isn't just a yes man to keep my business? Which is why I'm checking here.