An updated "check my plan" after I got roasted by FatFIRE
- Age
- 55
- Net Worth
- $5,200,000
Summary
The poster has a strong financial position with a net worth of $5.2 million, including $3.6 million in 401(k) and $600,000 in liquid assets. They are planning to retire at the end of 2024 when they turn 56, with a projected annual spending of $250,000 plus inflation. Their plan includes drawing $150,000 from their 401(k) and supplementing it with $125,000 from their savings until their pensions and Social Security start at ages 58 and 65, respectively. This strategy leaves them with a substantial liquid buffer of $400,000 to $600,000 for future needs or Roth conversions.
The Original Post
I posted a plan to FatFIRE and mostly got told to get back to work for two more years - which is probably the right answer. That made me go back and re-think things. I've sharpened the pencil bit, found more money, clarified some of the points that were confusing/unnecessary and hoping to get this sub's unvarnished and realistic criticism of my plan: Us: \- Both 55, one income, two teens. US HCOL \- 2 Kids headed to private college (fully funded 529, not included here) \- Want to FIRE end of 2024 (turning 56 in 2025) Assets: \- $3.6m 401k \- $600k liquid cash/brokerage accounts \- 2 Pensions totalling $175k/yr starting at age 58 \- Social Security \~ $65k kicks at age 65 \- \~$1m primary residence +various Real Estate (all paid off by RE), ignored as none is income generating. Pre-RE Cashflow: \- Earning $1.2m/yr but at 49% effective tax rate \- Projected spend will be $250k/yr. \- Prior 2 years non-accumulation spend grew to almost $300k ($100k non-discretionary), but currently managing to a $240k budget (our first ever!) which will allow us to add another $200k savings this year Planned post-RE spend will be $250k/yr + inflation \- Undergraduate College is covered. Any post-grad is not. \- Start drawing $150k from 401k (4%, rule of 55) \- Ages 56/57: Supplement that with $125k/yr from savings ($250k) \- After age 58, Pension of $175k starts, lowering 401k WR to $135k \- $65k Social Security starts at age 65 The above scenario leaves $400k-$600k liquid as a 2 year spend buffer, some of which may go to ROTH conversions to reduce RMDs, future kid/parent needs, etc or can grow in taxable accounts. Planned Scenario: https://engaging-data.com/will-money-last-retire-early/?spend=250000&initsav=4100000&age=56&yrs=45&stockpct=80&bondpct=18&cashpct=2&sex=0&infl=1&taxrate=25&fees=0.3&income=175000,%2065000&incstart=58,%2065&incend=99,%2099&expense=&expstart=56&expend=59&showdeath=1&showlow=1&show2x=1&show5x=1&flexpct=20&spendthreshold=80&mort=best Less aggressive scenario: https://engaging-data.com/will-money-last-retire-early/?spend=300000&initsav=3900000&age=56&yrs=45&stockpct=80&bondpct=18&cashpct=2&sex=0&infl=1&taxrate=25&fees=0.3&income=175000,%2065000&incstart=58,%2065&incend=99,%2099&expense=&expstart=56&expend=59&showdeath=1&showlow=1&show2x=1&show5x=1&flexpct=15&spendthreshold=70&mort=best