FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Nearly $10M at 55: Should I Risk Margin or Sell Concentrated Stock for $2M Dream Home?

r/fatFIRE
11/8/2025
Age
55
Net Worth
$9,900,000
Expenses
$150,000/yr
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Married couple with $9.9M planning to retire in 2026 at 55, strategically selling concentrated position while debating how to finance a $2M+ lakefront property purchase.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • Excellent tax planning staying below 20% LTCG bracket while DCAing out of concentrated position ($500K/year after taxes starting 2027). Smart cash cushion with $700K in T-Bills providing 4-5 years of spending ($175K/year floor). Strong diversification strategy across taxable ($5.7M), 401k ($2.7M), IRAs ($1M), and HSA ($125K) with awareness of NUA benefits on 401k concentrated position.

Areas to Focus

  • • Prioritize accelerating diversification out of the $4.8M concentrated stock position ($3.8M unrealized gains) before taking on a $2M+ home purchase - consider Option 3 with Exchange Fund to lock in 7-year diversification timeline while maintaining liquidity through continued DCA for the home purchase.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Concentrated position risk amplified by potential margin call exposure - with $4.8M in single stock (50% of portfolio) plus $700K in 401k same position, a 50% drop could trigger margin call while simultaneously crushing net worth and delaying retirement plans right as you're purchasing an illiquid $2M+ asset.

The Original Post

This is a follow up post from about a year ago: [Which path do you choose? : r/fatFIRE](https://www.reddit.com/r/fatFIRE/comments/1hb49aa/which_path_do_you_choose/) A specific shout out to u/shock_the_nun_key, u/Bob_Atlanta, u/Anonymoose2021 and a slew of others for their comments at that time. The follow up to the original post is that in 2025 we did a charitable 'bunch' and sold off a good chunk of the concentrated position while staying below the 20% LTGC bracket. The proceeds of which went into a 13-week rolling T-Bill ladder that was designed to give us \~5 years of $175K/year spend in the event of a market downturn until I can tap into my tIRA. Not going to chase ACA subsidies. At the start of 2025, my spouse and I agreed to DCA out of the concentrated position such that we stay out of the 20% LTCG fed tax bracket - with caveat that >90% of analysts that track the concentrated position say it's a buy or strong buy. Plan set! Ready to GFY cheers in the back half of 2026! Not so fast my friends! In October, my spouse has decided that now is the time to start seriously looking for some lakeshore property (no timeline on purchase - but actively looking).. Budget is upwards of $2M (but I wouldn't be surprised to see that push up to $2.5M). Below is current financial situation and fatFIRE timeline. \~9.5M in assets with the following breakdown: * Taxable: $5.7M * Concentrated stock \~$4.8M with \~$3.8M in gains * Rolling 13 week T-Bill: $700K * Other stocks: $200K * 401K (70% post tax / 30% pre tax): \~$2M (VOO) / $43K (LIRIX) / $700K (concentrated position) * I am very aware of NUA on the concentrated position in my 401K and when/how to deal with that. * Traditional IRA: $700K (VGIT) * Roth IRA: $300K (VOO) * HSA: $125K (60/40 portfolio) Additional details: * Current Annual spend: \~$150K/year * Desired Floor of spending in retirement: $175K/year * Desired ceiling of spending in retirement: $250-300K/year * Existing home equity: \~$400K (standard mortgage with $250K remaining and could sell current home for \~$650K) * Retiring in 2026 at age 55 * Margin Loan available at 4.9% through negotiated rate at Fidelity - Not using margin currently but available to us. The massive variable here is when (or if!) my spouse finds a place to be our 'forever' home. It could be next week, next year or in 5 years. However, I'm guessing in '26 or '27. One certainty is that we'll continue to DCA out of the concentrated position and keep enough cash/cash like positions to support a 7 year down market scenario with our desired floor of spending. Starting in '27 DCA'ing will net \~$500K/year after taxes. If the transaction happens by end of '27 I'm thinking two potential paths: 1. Use the margin loan with the end result of owning the home outright via DCA out of concentrated position. Pro: Most tax efficient. Con: Risk of being called in the event of 50-ish percent market drop of the concentrated position (likely would also macro drop in markets). Need to ensure I do whatever's needed to ensure that does not happen like move more of 401K from VOO to LIRIX for use if approach being margin called. 2. Continue to DCA and when it's time, sell off enough of the concentrated position to buy the lakeshore home. Pro: Own the thing outright plus instant 'diversification' out of concentrated position upon home purchase. Con: The tax hit 3. Put $2M of concentrated position in an Exchange Fund this year while continuing to DCA concentrated position into broad based ETF (ie VTI). When/if it's time to buy house sell concentrated position and, if needed the broad based ETF, to own home outright. Pro: Faster diversification out of concentrated position and owning home outright. Con: 7 year lock up of Exchange fund So. Which path would you choose? Are there others I should be considering? EDIT: Added a 3rd option and clarified margin is available but not being used for anything today.