Should This 56-Year-Old Government Worker Shift $23.5K into a Roth 457(b)?
- Age
- 56
- Net Worth
- $2,000,000
- Income
- $230,000/yr
- Profession
- Government Employee
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
This 56-year-old government worker with nearly $2M invested is considering shifting their $23.5K annual 457(b) contribution to a Roth account. With a high $230K income, they're in the 32% tax bracket but could potentially drop to 24% if they reduce overtime. The Roth 457(b) would allow tax-free withdrawals in retirement when their taxable income is expected to be $100K lower.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • This person has an impressive $2M invested across retirement accounts and is close to reaching their FIRE goals, likely able to retire within the next 2-7 years with a $30-40K pension.
Areas to Focus
- • Evaluate the tax implications of the Roth 457(b) option vs. continuing pre-tax contributions, considering their current high income and expected lower retirement income.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Their large retirement portfolio and pension may subject them to higher Medicare premiums, so they should factor that into their long-term planning.
The Original Post
My (government) employer is giving me the option to do my deferred compensation 457(b) as a Roth next year. The limit will be the same as pre-tax $23.5k or so. Would this be a good idea? My income this year will be about $230k. If it stays the same next year that would put me in the 32% bracket but conceivably if I slack on the OT I'll be back in 24%. I also have state income tax at 6% or possibly 6.85%. Currently I do a Backdoor Roth already and put $26k into a brokerage account. Budget-wise if I did the Roth 457(b) I would just put less in the brokerage account to make up for the taxes being paid. Currently I am 56 with just under $2M invested in 401(k), 457(b), Roth (less than $100k), HYSA. I plan to retire between 2 and 7 years from now and would have enough money to float me until the Roth 457(b) is 5 years old. I would also have a pension of about $30-40k, depending on when I retire. My retirement taxable income should be about $100k lower than my working income now.