FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

Retired at 55 with $1.3M: Should I Do Roth Conversions Before My $84k Pension Starts?

r/FinancialPlanning
11/21/2025
Age
57
Net Worth
$1,300,000
Income
$28,000/yr
Expenses
$70,000/yr
Profession
Retired
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Retired couple at 57 with $1.3M debating strategic $50k annual 401k withdrawals to minimize lifetime taxes before pension and Social Security kick in.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You retired at 55 with a solid $1.3M nest egg and secured pension income, demonstrating excellent planning. Your tax arbitrage strategy is spot-on - withdrawing $50k annually at 12% now versus 22-24% later could save $5k-6k per year in taxes. You're maintaining a conservative 2.3% return on your withdrawal bucket, protecting against sequence of returns risk in early retirement.

Areas to Focus

  • • Move that $400k stable value fund money into a tax-free Roth IRA through conversions during these low-income years (ages 57-61). Fill up the 12% bracket completely - you have room for up to $89k in conversions for married filing jointly, not just $50k.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Your $500k cash position is generating only $28k (5.6%) but you're spending $70k annually, depleting principal by $42k/year. This burns through $210k before your pension starts at 62. Consider moving some of that cash into higher-yielding Treasury bonds or CD ladders earning 4.5-5% to reduce drawdown.

The Original Post

I'm sure it has been asked before but I can never seem to find my specific scenario. I think I should withdraw $50k annually for the next 5 years before my pension kicks in at age 62. I have $400k in the Fidelity Stable value fund that only returns 2.3% annually. This is the money I would withdraw. Background information: Current Age 57, Married, no children. Retired at 55 so rule of 55 applies and there is no penalty to withdraw. I have $500k in cash savings and CDs outside of the 401k. This generates an annual income around $28k. I spend about $70k a year which is currently coming exclusively from the $500k mentioned above. Pension will start at 62. $7k a month SS for us will be $8k a month if taken at 67 and still is a thing. The $400k in the stable fund is \~20% of the overall balance. Expected income age 62 to 67 from pension and cash is about $110k. Expected income age 67 onward from pension, cash and SS is $200k My conclusion is I should 401k withdraw $50k now when my income is low, because all my income would be in the 12% federal tax rate for the next 5 years. If I wait until the pension starts at 62 it will be in the 22% or 24% tax bracket. Thoughts?