Retired at 55 with $1.3M: Should I Do Roth Conversions Before My $84k Pension Starts?
- Age
- 57
- Net Worth
- $1,300,000
- Income
- $28,000/yr
- Expenses
- $70,000/yr
- Profession
- Retired
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
Retired couple at 57 with $1.3M debating strategic $50k annual 401k withdrawals to minimize lifetime taxes before pension and Social Security kick in.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • You retired at 55 with a solid $1.3M nest egg and secured pension income, demonstrating excellent planning. Your tax arbitrage strategy is spot-on - withdrawing $50k annually at 12% now versus 22-24% later could save $5k-6k per year in taxes. You're maintaining a conservative 2.3% return on your withdrawal bucket, protecting against sequence of returns risk in early retirement.
Areas to Focus
- • Move that $400k stable value fund money into a tax-free Roth IRA through conversions during these low-income years (ages 57-61). Fill up the 12% bracket completely - you have room for up to $89k in conversions for married filing jointly, not just $50k.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Your $500k cash position is generating only $28k (5.6%) but you're spending $70k annually, depleting principal by $42k/year. This burns through $210k before your pension starts at 62. Consider moving some of that cash into higher-yielding Treasury bonds or CD ladders earning 4.5-5% to reduce drawdown.
The Original Post
I'm sure it has been asked before but I can never seem to find my specific scenario. I think I should withdraw $50k annually for the next 5 years before my pension kicks in at age 62. I have $400k in the Fidelity Stable value fund that only returns 2.3% annually. This is the money I would withdraw. Background information: Current Age 57, Married, no children. Retired at 55 so rule of 55 applies and there is no penalty to withdraw. I have $500k in cash savings and CDs outside of the 401k. This generates an annual income around $28k. I spend about $70k a year which is currently coming exclusively from the $500k mentioned above. Pension will start at 62. $7k a month SS for us will be $8k a month if taken at 67 and still is a thing. The $400k in the stable fund is \~20% of the overall balance. Expected income age 62 to 67 from pension and cash is about $110k. Expected income age 67 onward from pension, cash and SS is $200k My conclusion is I should 401k withdraw $50k now when my income is low, because all my income would be in the 12% federal tax rate for the next 5 years. If I wait until the pension starts at 62 it will be in the 22% or 24% tax bracket. Thoughts?