Should a 57-Year-Old Widow with $2M Pay Off Her 3.5% Mortgage?
- Age
- 57
- Net Worth
- $2,000,000
- Income
- $75,000/yr
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
A 57-year-old widow earning $75k with a $2M insurance payout weighs whether to pay off her 3.5% mortgage.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Maintaining a low 3.5% mortgage while investing the $2M life insurance payout at potentially higher returns is a solid financial strategy.
Areas to Focus
- • Evaluate the financial advisor's aggressive 9% return claim and consider keeping the low-interest mortgage.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Paying off the 3.5% mortgage creates a heavy opportunity cost when potential investment returns could outpace the interest rate.
The Original Post
I’m asking for a friend whose husband recently passed and left her a $2 million life insurance policy plus about $3k per month from spousal benefits of some sort. Other factors to consider: • She’s 57 years old • Still employed earning $75k/yr. • Her only daughter just started her 2nd year of college which costs $20k/yr. • 12 years remain on her 30-year 3.5% mortgage with a balance of $370,000 • She has no other debt Her CFP claims he should be able to earn an average rate of return of 9% annually on whatever funds he manages for her without taking too much risk considering her age and situation. She’ll likely have him manage her entire savings of $1.5 - $2 million. He advised her to first pay off her $370,000 mortgage balance. This makes no sense to me since she’s only paying 3 1/2% on that $370k, and he already claimed he could earn her 9% annually on that $370k. That would be an opportunity cost of $20,350 annually(370,000 x 5.5%). Plus, she would lose the mortgage interest tax right off. Maybe I’m simplifying this too much. What am I missing?