Should I Take the $160k Pension Buyout or Keep My Guaranteed $1,700/Month Payments?
- Age
- 58
- Net Worth
- $160,000
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
At 58 years old, this individual has the opportunity to take a $160,000 pension buyout or keep their guaranteed $1,700 monthly pension starting at age 65. With the buyout, they would need to invest the lump sum and outperform the pension's guaranteed returns, which may be a tall order.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • The guaranteed $1,700 monthly pension is a very valuable and low-risk income stream that would be difficult to replicate in an IRA. Unless you have extremely high investment returns, the pension is likely the better long-term option.
Areas to Focus
- • Carefully compare the present value of the pension payments vs. the lump sum buyout offer to make the most financially sound decision for your situation.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Relying too heavily on investment returns to replace a guaranteed pension payout could expose you to significant market risk in retirement.
The Original Post
My former employer offered to buyout my pension for $160K (i am 58 yrs male) but the lifetime benefit I get at 65 normal retirement would be $1,700 per month. On Schwab, that same annuity would cost nearly $189K to purchase so it seems like an IRA rollover would need to do extremely well to beat that guaranteed monthly payment of $1,700, any advice. One financial advisor told me that taking the buyout through a lumpsum payment was 95% of the time the best way to proceed so I am confused?