At $6.3M and 58, Should I Pay 1% to Beat the Market or Stay the Course?
- Age
- 58
- Net Worth
- $6,300,000
- FIRE Status
- On Track
Summary
58-year-old with $6.3M net worth retiring in 1 year, questioning if wealth manager worth 1% fee despite lifetime DIY success.
FIRE Analysis
Strengths
- • Successfully built $6.3M through disciplined DIY investing with diversified ETFs and index funds. Smart tax planning with Roth conversion strategies and IRMAA awareness shows sophisticated understanding. Strategic addition of bond ladder and commodities for retirement transition demonstrates proper risk management as you near retirement.
Areas to Focus
- • Skip the wealth manager - at your level of sophistication with tax planning spreadsheets and diversified portfolio, the 1% fee ($63k/year) will cost you $1.5M+ over 20 years with zero evidence they'll beat your index approach.
Potential Risk
- ⚠️ Two college tuitions plus lifestyle inflation in early retirement could drain reserves faster than expected - ensure your withdrawal rate accounts for 4-6 years of elevated education expenses before your spending stabilizes.
The Original Post
We have always been against paying someone 1% of our investment portfolio every year to manage it for us. We have been in a diversified portfolio of funds for our entire careers and in the past 5 years, switched to ETFs and, largely, index Funds and now ETFs, a small amount of commodities ETFs (mostly metals). As we prepare for retirement in the next year, we have added a bond fund and a small amount in a CTA and will do a bond ladder at retirement. We have cash flow and Roth conversion spreadsheets that we put together with help from Boldin and other tools and research to minimize taxes, IRMA and maximize spending availability and legacy planning. 58M, $6.3M NW which doesn’t include home and 529s, 2 children with one in college and one about to enter. However, as we get to the finish line, and we have amassed a sizable nest egg, I find myself wondering more and more whether there are peers that consistently ‘beat the market’ or benefit from a career wealth manager. We have a few friends and contacts that are wealth managers at large firms (i.e. JP morgan, Merrill) and I now have a few friends that are retiring soon or just retired that have wealth managers (but neither were in finance). I’ve taken a few meetings with Merrill and Fisher Investments and our guy at Schwab and they seem to be selling something ‘just behind the curtain’ there will be greater than market constant returns without more risk. Please let me know if you were skeptical like me and finally went to a wealth manager and found that it was a worthwhile use of your $$$ and “why”? What did they do that you couldn’t or didn’t want to do yourself. If you are happy with your professional, what do you spend each year on the advice? I am paranoid and untrusting, I watch too much American Greed, so please understand that I won’t respond to chat requests.