FIRE Summaries

SPY

Compare Your Progress

Discover where you rank on your FIRE journey

Enter your details to see how your net worth compares with others in your age group across different FIRE communities. This helps you understand your progress and set realistic goals.

$

74-Year-Old with $7M in IRAs Wants to Convert $5M in One Year - Genius or Tax Disaster?

r/FinancialPlanning
11/16/2025
Age
74
Net Worth
$7,070,000
Income
$300,000/yr
Location
New Jersey
FIRE Status
On Track

Summary

Retiree couple with $7M across Traditional and Roth IRAs, $300K annual income, seeking advice on mega Roth conversion to avoid Medicare surcharges and pass wealth tax-free to 3 children.

FIRE Analysis

Strengths

  • • You've built exceptional wealth with $7M in retirement accounts through disciplined saving. You're strategically thinking about tax efficiency with $2M already in Roth conversions. Your $300K pension/Social Security income provides a rock-solid foundation that covers lifestyle needs without touching principal.

Areas to Focus

  • • Avoid the mega conversion temptation - converting $5M at once could push you into the 37% federal bracket plus 10.75% NJ state tax, costing $2M+ in taxes when strategic annual conversions up to the 32% or 35% bracket threshold would save hundreds of thousands over time.

Potential Risk

  • ⚠️ Paying conversion taxes from IRA accounts creates a massive hidden cost - you're permanently reducing the tax-free compounding base and triggering immediate taxation on withdrawal amounts, essentially paying taxes on money used to pay taxes. Use taxable account funds instead to preserve maximum Roth growth potential for your children.

The Original Post

I want to convert our large balances of Traditional IRAs all at once. That is what I've been wanting to do but most people advise against it. Problem is the death by a thousand cuts-with IRMMA surcharges, Social Security taxes, NIIT, big RMDs, huge NJ Taxes etc. I'd prefer to take my punishment in one year and have it all over with. I would pay the taxes out of my IRAs. I started way too late. Not charitably inclined, so no QCD's advice, please. I will be 74(in Dec)-RMDs have already started at @$90K/yr. Husband is only 71 (72 in Feb) so he hasn't started RMDs yet. Pensions and Social Security for both of us is approx. $300K/(which includes the $90K RMD)year so we will never have less income than that until one of us dies. We are always going to be in a high tax bracket with our Traditional IRAs. I have $2M in Traditional and $2M in Roth as I have been doing Roth conversions the last few years. The problem is it adds to our income so we keep taking hits in taxes from Medicare, etc. He has $3M in Traditional and just $70K in Roth. He has another year to go before RMDs. Yes, I know we are blessed but we both came from nothing and worked hard and saved all our lives. So, to be constantly dinged and punished so we end up paying more for Medicare and taxes etc. than others is unfair. So, do you suggest I just convert the whole $5M this year, pay the taxes from the IRA accounts and end this pain! We want to pass this money on to our 3 children without the tax burden. Thank you for any advice you can offer.